It is often sparked by a high-profile athlete getting a concussion (Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson) to stir the buzz word “Concussion” around the sports and often non-sports worlds. For the longest of time, and as most recent as 2013, complete rest was the suggestion of many health care professionals, myself included. While this was a safe method, it often did not address some of the underlying pathologies associated with sport related concussion/ post-concussion syndrome. I want to highlight some of the actions I have taken for my athletes and patients that have been a better step in the right direction versus “just rest”
Cognitive Rest – We live in a very stimulating world. Our lifestyle is often conducive for recovery. Between our phones/computers/tablets/tv’s we are in a constant state of stimulation of noise, sounds and lights. This would be one of the only pieces of the original recommendations of rest that I find extremely important. Your daily cognitive load cannot make your symptoms worse if you are struggling with post-concussion symptoms. Anyone remember when Texas Tech Coach Mike Leach was fired over locking a player in a dark shed? (If not here you go: https://abcnews.go.com/US/texas-tech-university-football-coach-mike-leach-fired/story?id=9449169) As an outsider to the situation were his intentions good? Maybe. But definitely went about it the wrong way. So turn that phone on night mode, pick up a pair of blue-light blocking glasses if you must work on your computer for extended periods of time. Finally, talk to your health care provider about accommodating your current work or academic schedule so that you can take steps forward and not back.
GET ACTIVE – The last paragraph ends where I would say “Old School meets New School”. Exercise is a must and an early application to the recovery. The Buffalo Concussion Treadmill Test (BCTT) has become a front runner in safe return to exercise with concussion/post-concussion symptoms. More information on the BCTT can be found here: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6492460/
Vestibulo-Ocular Dysfunction – This is not my expertise. This is not an area I am thoroughly trained to evaluate and treat. Like all health care workers it is important for me to recognize when my patients are not improving. This could be the very reason. Patients struggling from this following a concussion will have trouble with visual acuity, double vision, fogginess, motion sensitivity, difficulty concentrating or focusing. If these symptoms do not subside it is beneficial to seek care from someone who specializes in their treatment: vestibular physical therapist, neuro-opthalmologist, neuro-optometrist.
Cervical Spine Dysfunction – Let’s call this my wheel house. This is an area I see the most success with my athletes and patients when it comes to concussions and post-concussion. A study performed in Canada in spring of 2019 of 266 pediatric sport related concussions, the authors found that 32.5% of the patients also suffered from cervical spine dysfunction (CSD). The authors then concluded that those that had CSD in addition to their concussion were 3.95 times more likely to have a delayed recovery versus those that didn’t have CSD (28.5 days vs 17 days). Link to the study below. This is pretty telling how powerful and important the head on neck, neck on body relationship is. If there is limitations in the motion or function of the neck it plays directly into how the brain is able to function and recover.
I did a previous piece on breathing and its importance to our overall health status, which can be found here: https://drbrianregan.com/2019/11/13/take-a-deep-breath/. For connecting some dots, I want to include some of that writing now. The fluid surrounding your brain, cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), plays a vital role in our daily function by providing nutrition and waste removal for the brain. It was at one point believed that its primary function was to balance the pressure within the skull. As the pulse of blood entered the skull, the skull could not compress or expand. The CSF would then pulse just the same and exit the skull, maintaining equilibrium, or balancing the system.
Advances in MRI imaging have completely changed our interpretation of this lifeblood. We are now able to measure the fluid and its movement throughout the body without sticking a needle in the spine, or opening up the skull. Researchers have determined that respiration is a major component, if not the most important component, in your bodies ability to effectively move CSF. Anecdotally if we are able to stimulate the flow of CSF through the brain, could we accelerate the brain’s ability to recover. Or uncork the plug that may be limiting the brains recovery in the first place. We know that with concussions the brain cell’s metabolism essentially has gone “haywire”. If we could provide that cell with appropriate nutrition and waste reduction, we could in turn help it recover.
Parasympathetic Stimulation- There is an additional benefit to the deep breathing techniques. We know that deep breathing will help stimulate our parasympathetic nervous system. This is also more commonly known as our “Rest-and-Digest” portion of our nervous system. Amplifying the “Rest-and-Digest” portion of your nervous system will help you have better sleep and recover better during that sleep. I recommend all of my patients to perform slow and deep diaphragmatic breaths while they are lying in bed to help “down regulate” and slow their body down prior to sleeping. This is also a tactic that can be used when performing an activity that is aggravating post-concussion symptoms to halt those symptoms from getting worse.
Magnesium- What started as a cue from Ben Greenfield from his book Boundless (https://www.amazon.com/Boundless-Upgrade-Brain-Optimize-Aging/dp/1628603976) has now gained traction in the concussion research. Ben originally wrote about magnesium being able to attenuate blood brain barrier permeability. Now double blinded research has surfaced supporting the application of magnesium during the acute stage of concussions. High dose IV supplementation has been found to be neuroprotective in severe cases of traumatic brain injuries. Authors of this study (https://www.ajemjournal.com/article/S0735-6757(20)30348-X/fulltext) believe that magnesium will decrease symptoms sooner and allow a faster return to baseline.
Complexity- At this point I hope you have assumed the complexity that can be brought on with concussions and how 1-sized fits all management is not always ideal. Whether you are a health care provider or a patient, please seek the appropriate health care provider to help guide you or your patients to recovery. Let’s not sit back and say “it’ll be get better with time”
Disclaimer: This Content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. It is extremely important if you are struggling with a concussion or the aftermath of a concussion to find a health professional that is experienced in treating and managing concussions. It is paramount for you to find someone that can help jumpstart your recovery.
Sources:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6306465/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32318012/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29393810/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30045221/
https://cdn-links.lww.com/permalink/jsm/a/jsm_2020_01_28_haider_19-313_sdc1.pdf
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28152239
https://www.jneurosci.org/content/jneuro/35/6/2485.full.pdf
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6089233/pdf/nihms976674.pdf